Happenings, book reviews, new publications, upcoming events, the latest from the blog and more.
View this email in your browser
HCG is a broad-based group of trainers, teachers and experts from multiple disciplines committed to deep diversity, equity and social justice. The purpose of our newsletter is to share what we're up to and to highlight resources, organizations and folks in the struggle working for a more equitable and healthy world. We are so thankful to be in community with you and  welcome your feedback.  If you have content you would like to share with our online learning community of
almost 2,400 people, please send it our way.

“To build community requires vigilant awareness of the work we must continually do to undermine all the socialization that leads us to behave in ways that perpetuate domination.”  ―
bell hooks, Teaching Community: A Pedagogy of Hope
Table of Contents
  • HCG Highlights - Dr. Hackman's closing keynote at the Equity in the Center Summit
  • Featured Upcoming HCG Presentations & Events - ACPA and White Privilege Conferences coming up March, 2019.  Don't miss Dr. Heather Hackman at either.
  • Featured Organization - National Indigenous Women's Resource Center
  • Conferences & Events We Support - A list of recommendations for upcoming conferences and events focused on racial, economic, social, environmental and food justice.
  • Recommended Resources - Videos, articles, blog posts, podcasts, current research & other links we've learned from and liked recently! Let us know if you have something to add.
  • Book Review - HCG is deleting all of its social media accounts! WHAT!? Find out why here.
HCG Highlight
Watch Dr. Hackman's closing keynote (1:02) from the Equity in the Center Summit in Baltimore this past October. Or a 4ish minute trailer of it here!
"I'm pretty certain you've seen the great video we captured of your AMAZING keynote. I'm still getting emails about how great you were." - Andrew Plumley, Sr. Program Mgr.
Featured Upcoming HCG Presentations & Conference Workshops
January 25, 2019
Cypress College, California
Keynote on social justice and teaching

February 11, 2019
The Corps Network Conference, Washington DC 
Keynote on developing and utilizing a racial equity lens

February 18, 2019
Auburn University, Alabama
Keynote on the connections between campus sustainability work and social justice issues
  • Pre-Conference Institute with Tanya Williams and Dr. Hackman
  • Dr. Hackman will be delivering conference workshops on gender and race
Dr. Heather Hackman will be delivering a keynote address at the 2019 White Privilege Conference

March 20-23 in Cedar Rapids, IA
Cedar Rapids Convention Complex
Registration is open
Featured Organization
National Indigenous Women's Resource Center
The National Indigenous Women's Resource Center, Inc. (NIWRC) is a Native nonprofit organization that was created specifically to serve as the National Indian Resource Center (NIRC) Addressing Domestic Violence and Safety for Indian Women.

The Mission of NIWRC is to support and uphold grassroots advocacy by creating and enhancing the capacity of Native communities to end gender based violence through technical assistance, education, public awareness and policy development.

Key principles to ending gender-based violence are:

  • To support grassroots efforts
  • Provide national leadership
  • Develop educational and programmatic materials
  • Provide direct technical assistance
  • Build capacity of Indigenous communities
  • Support tribal sovereignty

Vision: NIWRC’s vision is to restore safety of Native women and their communities by upholding the inherent sovereignty of Indigenous Peoples.

Donate to the NIWRC
Conferences & Events We Support
CTA Equity & Human Rights Conference
March 1-3, 2019 in San Jose, CA

Diversity Abroad Conference
March 2-5, 2019 in Boston, MA

March 3-6, 2019 in Boston, MA

National Association of Diversity Officers in Higher Ed. Annual Conference
March 6-9, 2-19 in Philadelphia, PA

White Privilege Conference 20
March 20-23, 2019 in Cedar Rapids, Iowa

Association of American Colleges & Universities
Diversity, Equity, and Student Success Conference
March 28-30, 2-19 in Pittsburgh, PA

National Summit for Educational Equity
April 28-May 2, 2019 in Arlington, VA

NCORE Conference
May 28-June 1, 2019 in Portland, OR

International Drug Policy Reform Conference
Nov. 6-9, 2019 in St. Louis, Missouri

Recommended Articles & Resources
LA Teachers’ Strike Ends Following New Deal To Decrease Class Sizes

After a six-day strike, 30,000 teachers and staff members will return to work.

Gov't Says Thousands More Migrant Children Were Separated From Families Than Reported

The Trump administration began its family separation policy
earlier than what was originally reported.

The Part About MLK White People Don’t Like to Talk About
Dr. King was widely disliked for his message of liberation for oppressed people in this country—Black people, Brown people, Native people, all poor people.

YES! Magazine
How James Baldwin’s Writings About Love Evolved

The author is best known for arguing that emotional connection could help heal America’s racial divides. But his 1974 novel If Beale Street Could Talk focused instead on the bonds that held black people together.

The Atlantic

Late-night hosts examined the videos of students appearing to confront a Native American veteran and Trump’s shutdown offer
The Guardian

Stop Trusting Viral Videos
The Atlantic

The new elite’s phoney crusade to save the world –
without changing anything

The Guardian
Justice in America Podcast

Justice in America, hosted by Josie Duffy Rice and Clint Smith, is a podcast for everyone interested in criminal justice reform— from those new to the system to experts who want to know more.
Why You Couldn’t Find Big Media Coverage of Haaland and Davids
Time has run out to convince colonized newsrooms that Indigenous issues and perspectives are necessary to the national narrative.
YES! Magazine
A program that doubles the spending power for food stamp recipients who buy fresh produce just got more funding.
YES! Magazine
Why the Climate Change Message Isn’t Working
Threats of global catastrophe won’t move people to action.
Only the heart can inspire zeal.
YES! Magazine
Book Review
Deleting Social Media
(To the reader: This is both a blog and a book review)
By Dr. Heather Hackman
We at HCG have been considering deleting our social media accounts for quite some time, but were caught in the (erroneous) belief that doing so would be too detrimental to our work (getting our work out and keeping up with the work of others). We had an inkling that these platforms were not on the up and up given Facebook’s value as a multibillion dollar enterprise (roughly $139 billion as of July 2018) while offering a “free” service to 2.3 billion monthly active users. Nothing is really free in the realm of the corporatocracy and thus Facebook’s services, Google’s search engine and gmail (3.5 billion searches a day and worth over $239 billion), and the like…none of them are really free. Not being very tech savvy, however, we were not able to pinpoint exactly “why” we did not trust these venues and the benevolence of their services and so we stayed.
Adding to our discomfort was the persistence of trolling on these platforms and the ease with which even the most affable of folks turned into truly awful people, saying things they would never dream of saying face to face. Lindy West wrote about her troll (Shrill, 2016) and noted that when she met him, he seemed like a nice enough guy who really had no idea why he chose such a cruel response to her - it just seemed so easy and he kind of went with it. The combination of the shadowy nature with which these platforms operate, the social detritus that they seem to encourage, and the way they influence our society in lowest-common-denominator ways all pointed to “leave social media”. And yet, we still did not. It’s gravitational pull was quite strong, and that coupled with a little FOMO made us stay. Additionally, it does not appear to be a decision anyone else is making and so we were hesitant to do it. Then the switch flipped. A year of problematic headlines for various social media giants, the most visible of which were the revelations regarding the 2016 presidential election and our reading of Jaron Lanier’s book, Ten Arguments for Deleting Your Social Media Accounts Right Now, 2018, tipped the scales and convinced us to leave all social media. Viewed as one of social media’s / the tech world’s key players, it is all the more poignant that he advocates abandoning the current iteration of social media. Not being a “tech skeptic”, and definitely not a luddite, his insider reasoning is clearly laid out in ten arguments (listed below). Embedded across his “ten reasons” are a few key themes that were compelling to us and perhaps they will be to you as well.
In one theme he underscores how the business model for these platforms pushes them to increasingly mine, store and sell every bit of personal information you share. Some social media users often compare this to TV ads and say they do not mind the data sharing given that services are free. What almost all of us do not understand about this process, however, is that the data then gets utilized by algorithms designed to craft and cater information in line with that personal data. Thus, there is an ever-increasing “bubble” effect. More insidiously, the algorithms use this information to deeply but subtly manipulate the user into increased behavior modification that serves corporations buying the data – what the platforms call “user engagement” but what Lanier describes as intense and ongoing manipulation. He highlights how social media users may “think” we are exercising free will when expressing interest in a particular product/headline/action, but in fact we are being constantly (and he means constantly) manipulated, herded if you will, in one direction or another. The free business model is not at all free and we are not the users of social media, we are actually the commodity that major corporations (the real users) are buying from social media platforms. Our free will within these settings is, in the long run, a myth as the highly sophisticated algorithms continually adapt to our “preferences” and feed us more of what we think our “preferences” are.
The second major theme is what this does to us as people. In short, he says it makes us “assholes” (argument three). The algorithms arc to what sparks strong reactions in us. Citing cognitive psychology sources, Lanier says that tends to be negative emotions, comments, or responses. The loudest jerk, then, gets the most attention leading the algorithms to adapt in that direction. In this light the corresponding erosion of our public discourse on social media makes a lot more sense – if the platform algorithms respond to the most robust responses, and if negative responses are easier to trigger, land more loudly and energetically, and in the end are the more “robust,” then the algorithms more consistently adapt in that direction. Social media celebrities who are brazen and off the rails get more hits and likes than do those who make measured critiques, consider multiple views and are grounded in care and respect. The quintessential example he gives is Donald Trump whom he says is by no means an anomaly, but is instead the likely outcome of social media platforms whose core programs favor that tonal narrative. Of course, everyday folks fall into that trend as well. In the end, to get more views, likes and to be validated on social media, you have to be a bit of an asshole.
The third major theme is what social media does to our society. Lanier says it makes us callous, it deeply obscures truth and the need to be truly well informed, and it herds us into what appear to be highly polarized camps, even though US society is actually not as polarized as mainstream media would have us think. As the algorithms continue to show us the bubbles of our “choices” we lose the ability to understand someone else’s point of view. One of the most vital elements of a democracy is the ability to talk across difference and find some measure of common ground. These platforms make that virtually impossible and thereby erode one of the basic needs of a thriving democracy. Place on top of that the ease with which interests outside the US are able to influence our democracy, and we have a toxic combination for a democratic society (which can eventually lead to the loss of that same democracy). Lanier points out the parallel rise of increasingly authoritarian regimes with the rise of social media platforms. He is not at all directly blaming these platforms, but he is noticing that in their current form, they are easy and powerful tools for authoritarianism - an ideology that does not encourage critical thought, lives through curt slogans and xenophobic frameworks, and encourages conformity to the power structure. He does acknowledge that certain social movements of late have benefited from the wide reach of social media (BLM and #MeToo), but then says the short term benefits of these do not actually outweigh the power of the wizard behind the curtain. And to the extent that these movements are able to gain traction, the algorithmic wizard(s) are more expeditiously working to co-opt, manipulate and redirect the work of those movements. Thus, the net is a loss for our society, a loss that no short term gain can justify.
As a book, Jaron Lanier’s ten reasons are a bit repetitive and their interrelation makes the identification of ten seem a bit inflated. I understand this move in terms of having catchy points as well as the need to repeat points to help the reader “get” what are often abstract and opaque dynamics for the “everyday” person, but it makes for dull reading at times. The lack of literary prowess should not deter one from reading this book and taking on its core points – the major social media platforms are not good for our society, they are not good for our personal growth and well-being, and they are not the “open” platforms we think they are. Rather, they are the tools of mega rich corporations for other mega rich corporations. Social media as an idea is not the problem, but social media that operates as these companies currently do is. Thus, deleting our accounts is the only way to get the attention of these companies and will eventually (hopefully) pave the way to the creation of other, more democratic social media platforms. 
But beyond deletion being a strategic approach to forcing complete reform of these systems, there is of course a deep moral imperative here. Lanier references in one of his points the work of Sherry Turkle (Reclaiming Conversation, 2015) and uses her comments on our connectivity to broach the notion of what it means to be human and how these platforms do not well serve our humanity. AI advocates might suggest that as menial work is taken care of, we are able to actually be more human and explore greater arenas of thought and action than before. Perhaps, but that is not this. What we have here is a deep loss of who we are as humans. The very notion that one can govern via tweets, let alone address the complexities of the human experience via Twitter, Facebook, What’s App, or Instagram, is absurd. And yet each day we increasingly accept it as the norm. A range of contemporary articles have shared how much better the authors feel about themselves, the world and their relationships after getting off social media. Similar studies have piled up regarding the deleterious impacts on self-esteem, interpersonal communication, and empathy as a result of the ongoing use of social media as a primary source of news, communication and relationships. This clearly does not serve social justice.
A tenet of social justice work is to take action and live as part of the solution. We at HCG do not pretend even for a minute that we “have arrived” with respect to living socially just lives, but we do commit to the interrogation of our choices and an honest appraisal of their support of justice. And for us, social media does not at all support social justice. To organizers – yes, there is great power in social media, but is it possible that we / you are being allowed to organize so the conglomerates can find ever more insidious ways to manipulate us? To those who say it creates access – is it possible that we are being granted access only to then create more avenues for control? I could go on, but it is easier for you to read Lanier’s book. At the deepest level, it is critical to ask if these platforms truly serve justice and our society. Having had a moment to consider it and take in more information we unequivocally say no. Justice is transparent, it is rooted in love, it is connected in ways that are abiding and authentic, and it serves the greater good. Learning what we have about social media, there is no way that it, in its current form, can be framed as serving the social good.
To be sure there are those for whom deleting social media accounts is not possible economically, politically, or socially. But, for those of us where it is possible, it is a critically important move to make. Thus, HCG is deleting all of its social media accounts as of January 31st. If you want to be in touch with us, please feel free to email us at the link on our website or at the top of our newsletter.
Jaron Lanier’s “Ten Arguments for Deleting Your Social Media Accounts Right Now”:
1. You are losing your free will
2. Quitting social media is the most finely targeted way to resist the insanity of our times
3. Social media is making you into an asshole
4. Social media is undermining truth
5. Social media is making what you say meaningless
6. Social media is destroying your capacity for empathy
7. Social media is making you unhappy
8. Social media doesn’t want you to have economic dignity
9. Social media is making politics impossible
10. Social media hates your soul
Blog Update
Want to get notified about HCG blog posts as soon as they go live? All you have to do is follow HCG on Google+, Twitter, Facebook or LinkedIn (see those handy buttons at the top of the newsletter? Click there!) and you'll be notified each time we post a new blog. Or, better yet, get new blog posts delivered directly to your inbox by subscribing to the RSS feed through the button below.
HCG Blog Button and RSS Subscription
Copyright © *|2016|* *|Hackman Consulting Group|*, All rights reserved.

Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list

Email Marketing Powered by Mailchimp